There is a particular kind of quiet that settles over Loftus Versfeld when the supporters in yellow realise the afternoon is not going to turn. Sundowns supporters have now heard it twice in sixteen days. Once on a Friday night in October, as Wiliete held on. Again on Sunday, in the rain, as USM Alger walked off with the Super Cup. So, what next for Sundowns? Not a collapse. Something more interesting than that: a season that has lost its biggest stage, and a cup semi-final against Kaizer Chiefs that has quietly become a referendum on everything else.
Our Super Cup report has Sunday’s goals and the storm, and our report on the Wiliete second leg has the night the holders went out. This column is about what those two nights cost Miguel Cardoso’s side, what they did not cost, and why Amakhosi are suddenly carrying the weight of a whole season.
What Wiliete really took
Start with the loss that lasts. In May, Sundowns beat AS FAR 2-1 on aggregate to become champions of Africa for the second time, after 2016, CAF records. Five months later their defence ended in the second preliminary round, the last door before the group stage: 0-0 in Angola, 1-1 in Pretoria, and out on away goals, CAF confirmed. TimesLIVE and iDiski Times both note it is the first time since 2015 that Sundowns have failed to reach the group stage.
When CAF made the draw in Cairo, it was Wiliete, a club founded only in 2018, that went into Group A alongside EspĂ©rance and Petro AtlĂ©tico. Orlando Pirates are South Africa’s only club left in the competition, in Group C with RS Berkane, Simba SC and Colombe Sportive, and the group stage opens on the weekend of 27 to 29 November, CAF’s draw page shows.
Our view: that is the real wound. For a decade the Champions League has been the competition that gave Sundowns’ domestic dominance its meaning. League titles were expected; Africa was the exam. Without it, every trophy left on the table has to work harder to justify the season.
Two nights, one pattern
The moment the Wiliete tie flipped has had its own column: The Turning Point on that soft pass back explains how one away goal rewrote the arithmetic. Sunday had no single moment like that. It had a run of bad luck and then a run of errors.
Cardoso lost Nuno Santos in the warm-up and Brayan Leon early in the match, CAF and TimesLIVE report. Santos is no ordinary absentee: his two headers beat Al-Ahli at the same ground in September, according to TimesLIVE. In comments published by CAF on Monday, Cardoso pointed to both injuries and to a rain-soaked pitch that did not suit a side built to pass the ball on the ground. Then, to his credit, he said none of it was an excuse, and that his team had made first-half mistakes of the kind such games punish.
He is right, and it is the thread that ties the two nights together. On both nights Sundowns had more of the game, by CAF’s account of the Wiliete night and TimesLIVE’s of Sunday, and still lost the decisive moments. Against Wiliete it was one loose ball. Against USM Alger it was a goal conceded inside four minutes and three in all. That is not a problem of quality. It is a problem of concentration under pressure, at home, in matches with a continental trophy attached.
The fortnight in numbers
Here is the part the anger skips: between those two nights, Sundowns kept winning. Count every game from Wiliete to USM Alger and there are five: a draw, three wins and a defeat.
| Opponent | Competition | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Wiliete | CAF Champions League | 1-1, out on away goals |
| Marumo Gallants | Knockout cup, last 16 | Won 1-0 |
| Durban City | Premiership | Won 4-1 |
| Golden Arrows | Knockout cup, quarter-final | Won 1-0 |
| USM Alger | CAF Super Cup | Lost 3-1 |
Sources: CAF, the PSL and ScoreLine’s fact-checked reports.
Eight goals scored, five conceded, and both cup ties won without conceding. That is the record of a strong side having a bad fortnight, not a broken one. The trouble is which two matches got away: the only two that carried African weight.
What next for Sundowns: the season is still enormous
Now look at what is still on the table.
| Competition | Where Sundowns stand |
|---|---|
| Premiership | First, 26 points from 10 games |
| MTN8 | Won, 2-0 against Orlando Pirates in Durban |
| FIFA African-Asian-Pacific Cup | Won, 2-1 against Al-Ahli at Loftus |
| Knockout cup | Semi-final against Kaizer Chiefs |
| FIFA Challenger Cup | Qatar, Saturday 12 December |
The PSL’s log has Sundowns top, one point clear of Pirates, who have a game in hand. The MTN8 came on 10 October at Moses Mabhida Stadium, Teboho Mokoena and a late Iqraam Rayners penalty settling it, Flashscore and AfricaSoccer reported. And September’s win over Al-Ahli earned a FIFA Challenger Cup tie in Qatar on 12 December against the winner of the Derby of the Americas, which pits Toluca against the Copa Libertadores champions, according to Paris Saint-Germain’s official site, AfricaSoccer and Flashscore. Win that, and Paris Saint-Germain wait in the Intercontinental Cup final on 16 December.
And CAF confirmed in May that the Champions League title already secured Sundowns a place at the FIFA Club World Cup in 2029. Wiliete cannot take that away.
Two trophies, a league lead and a date with the world’s club game in December. Most clubs on this continent would call that a good season. At Sundowns, after Wiliete, it feels like the consolation prize. That gap between what Sundowns have and what they expect is exactly why the semi-final matters so much.
Chiefs, the mirror image
Kaizer Chiefs arrive at this tie from a very similar place. On the same Friday night that Wiliete knocked Sundowns out, Chiefs beat Red Arrows 1-0 in Durban, CAF reported, only to go out of the Confederation Cup 3-2 on penalties after 1-1 on aggregate, as CAF and TimesLIVE both confirmed. Both semi-finalists lost Africa on the same night.
In the league, Chiefs are fifth on 14 points from nine games, the PSL log shows, and they had no part in the MTN8 final. In this cup, though, they have found something: 3-0 against TS Galaxy, then the comeback against Siwelele that our Polokwane report describes, a substitute’s late winner after falling behind and missing a penalty.
The last time these two met, at FNB Stadium in August, Langelihle Phili put Chiefs ahead on 62 minutes and Cassius Mailula equalised off the bench on 75, according to Kaizer Chiefs and TimesLIVE. It finished 1-1.
History says this cup bites back
Sundowns have unfinished business with this competition. They reached the 2024 final and lost it 2-1 to Magesi in Bloemfontein, SuperSport and FARPost reported, with Rayners scoring for Sundowns that night too.
Rayners is the link worth watching: the only goal against Golden Arrows, the penalty against USM Alger and the clincher in the MTN8 final were all his.
What the semi-final now carries
The draw paired Sundowns with Chiefs, and Stellenbosch with Pirates. The PSL has not yet confirmed venues or kick-off times, so we will not guess at them. What the league’s cup page does already list is a date for the final, 12 December, with the venue to be confirmed. That is the same Saturday as Sundowns’ date in Qatar. AfricaSoccer and Flashscore report that if Sundowns reach the final, the FIFA fixture takes priority and the domestic final would have to move. Sundowns’ success, in other words, could rewrite the calendar.
First comes the international break. SAFA has included Ronwen Williams and Teboho Mokoena in Bafana Bafana’s squad for Kenya, at home on Friday 13 November and in Nairobi on Tuesday 17 November. Cardoso gets time to think. He does not get all of his players to think with.
Our view: for Chiefs, the semi-final is a route to a final and the chance to beat Sundowns at their lowest point of the season. For Sundowns, it is something heavier. Win, and the two Loftus nights become a bad fortnight in a season with a third trophy in sight and Qatar to come. Lose, and the story of Mamelodi Sundowns this season becomes the story of a team that came up short every time the stakes rose. Unfair on a side top of the league? Yes. It is also how football remembers.
The quiet at Loftus will not last. What fills it depends on one cup tie against Chiefs.
Frequently asked questions
Why are Sundowns out of the CAF Champions League?
Wiliete of Angola knocked them out in the second preliminary round. The first leg in Angola finished 0-0 and the second leg at Loftus Versfeld on 23 October ended 1-1, so Wiliete went through on away goals, CAF confirmed. It is the first time since 2015 that Sundowns have missed the group stage.
What trophies have Sundowns won this season?
They beat Al-Ahli 2-1 at Loftus on 19 September to win the FIFA African-Asian-Pacific Cup, and they beat Orlando Pirates 2-0 in the MTN8 final in Durban on 10 October.
When do Sundowns play in the FIFA Challenger Cup?
On Saturday 12 December 2026 in Qatar, against the winner of the Derby of the Americas between Toluca and the Copa Libertadores champions. The winner meets Paris Saint-Germain in the FIFA Intercontinental Cup final on 16 December.
When is Sundowns v Kaizer Chiefs in the knockout cup semi-final?
The draw has paired the two clubs, with Stellenbosch against Orlando Pirates in the other semi-final. The PSL had not confirmed venues or kick-off times when we checked on 10 November.
Are Sundowns still top of the Premiership?
Yes. The PSL’s log has Sundowns first on 26 points from 10 games, one point ahead of Orlando Pirates, who have played a game fewer. Kaizer Chiefs are fifth on 14 points from nine games.


