Nobody in green and gold was beaten by much this weekend, and that is exactly why it stings. Bafana Bafana were a minute from a win in Soweto. The Springboks were one conversion from a draw in Paris. The Proteas had Bangladesh at 121 for 5 at the Wanderers and still went to bed on Sunday behind the game.
Call it a Springboks Bafana Proteas weekend of nearly. Three national teams, three days, and every one of them held the upper hand at some point. None of them kept it. The results and the quotes live in our reports, linked below. This is about what it all meant, and why the coming week now matters more than the one we have just lived through.
The big weekend theme: a Springboks Bafana Proteas weekend of control that slipped
Look at where each side stood at its best moment. In Soweto, Bafana were 2-1 up deep into the second half, with most of the chances behind them. At the Wanderers, Kagiso Rabada had five wickets inside 35 overs and the Bangladesh tail was in sight. In Paris the shape was turned around: the Boks were the side chasing, and, a man down for 20 minutes of it, they dragged a 21-7 half-time deficit back to 21-19, with a kick to level it.
Then each moment passed. Ryan Ogam’s goal a minute from time meant Bafana flew to Nairobi with seven points instead of nine (how Friday unfolded). At the Wanderers, Towhid Hridoy and Litton Das stayed together for almost 300 balls, until Marco Jansen trapped Hridoy with the final delivery of the day. In Paris the conversion that would have squared it was missed, and France held on (the full story from the Stade de France).
The thread is not bad luck, and it is not a crisis. All three sides showed they can take hold of a Test or a qualifier against good opposition. What none of them managed was the finish, and at this level the finish is the whole job. The good news is that every one of these stories is still open. Day two starts this morning. Nairobi is tomorrow. Dublin is on Saturday.
What we took from it
1. Best performance: Relebohile Mofokeng, in the middle of everything
Friday will be remembered for its last minute. Relebohile Mofokeng deserves to be remembered for the rest of it. In both full-time reports we read, from The Citizen and iDiski Times, he is at the centre of nearly everything good Bafana did.
He made the opening goal happen without touching the ball: his pressure hurried Amos Wanjala into turning it past his own goalkeeper after nine minutes. He made one of the best early chances, killing a long pass from Aubrey Modiba with one touch for Tshepang Moremi, who fired over. Just before the hour his curling shot came back off the post. And when Bafana finally went 2-1 up, Mofokeng finished it, after Oswin Appollis found him wide and Lyle Foster laid the ball back. iDiski Times counts it as his third senior international goal.
On a night when Bafana’s finishing let them down, his end product kept arriving. In Nairobi, the plan should begin with getting him the ball.
2. Biggest concern: Bok discipline, with no margin left
The Fan Seat made its case on Sunday that Paris was lost in the first half (read it here), and we will not argue it again. Our worry is narrower, and it travels with the squad to Dublin: discipline.
SA Rugby’s own report puts it plainly. Two cards for dangerous play in one Test, and both landed at the worst time. Lood de Jager’s yellow, 12 minutes in, came just as South Africa had a scrum to attack from, and France scored twice while he sat it out. Jasper Wiese’s 20-minute red, four minutes into the second half, left the Boks a man short until the 65th minute of a game they were trying to chase down. The Citizen counted 11 penalties conceded in all.
In an ordinary November the Boks could absorb that. This is not an ordinary November. Their route to the final now runs through one Test in Dublin, and Daily Maverick points out that the Boks have not won there while scoring four tries since 1951. A team that may need tries cannot spend ten minutes a man down.
3. What you may have missed: Wales did the Boks the biggest favour of the weekend
If you went to bed on Friday thinking Paris had ended the hunt for a final, Cardiff changed the picture on Saturday. Wales beat New Zealand 35-28 at the Principality Stadium, their first win over the All Blacks since 1953, built on five tries and a second half in which they held New Zealand up over the line three times.
The All Blacks still left with two losing bonus points, so they lead the southern standings by a point, 22 to 21 in The Citizen’s table, a gap the All Blacks’ own match report confirms. Before Saturday, New Zealand simply had to keep winning. Now both sides have work to do in the last round: New Zealand against England in London, earlier on Saturday, and the Boks against Ireland. Whoever finishes top goes to the final at Twickenham at the end of the month. A Welsh side very few gave a chance has put the Boks back in a race that looked lost.
4. The Wanderers: Bangladesh have come to compete
Before Sunday, Bangladesh had played eight Tests in South Africa and lost the lot, as AFP noted on the eve of the match. By stumps on day one they had already posted their highest total in this country, 327 for 6, and Hridoy had become only the second Bangladesh batter to score a Test century here.
Rabada’s 5 for 51, his 18th five-wicket haul in Tests, deserved a bigger reward, and the build-up to this Test is in our first Test preview. The meaning is simpler. At 121 for 5 the Proteas were entitled to expect a short innings, and the tourists refused to give them one. That is not a collapse waiting to happen. That is a side that has come to compete.
Our view: this Test is still there to be won, with four Bangladesh wickets left. But it will be won by a home attack that adjusts, not one that waits for the visitors to fold.
What it means next
All three stories resolve this week.
| When (SAST) | Fixture | Where |
|---|---|---|
| Today, from 10:00 | Proteas v Bangladesh, first Test, day two | The Wanderers, Johannesburg |
| Tuesday 17 November, 18:00 | Kenya v South Africa, AFCON 2027 qualifier | Nyayo National Stadium, Nairobi |
| Saturday 21 November, 18:40 | Ireland v South Africa, Nations Championship | Dublin |
| Monday 23 November, 10:00 | Proteas v Bangladesh, second Test | SuperSport Park, Centurion |
Bafana’s Tuesday carries a catch. Guinea, a point behind them, play Eritrea tonight, and because Kenya are co-hosts and already through, CAF sends only the best of the other three teams in Group D to the finals. SAFA’s report from the camp names the Nyayo National Stadium; the 18:00 kick-off is CAF’s, as SAFA’s match page still lists it as to be confirmed. Our analysis of the draw explains how one late goal changed the sums.
For the Boks, the 18:40 kick-off in Dublin is from SA Rugby’s match centre, on a day when New Zealand play England first. The first Test runs to Thursday before the series moves to Centurion.
So that was the weekend: three national teams who proved they belong in the fight, and then let the fight get away from them. None of them needs tearing up. All of them need a finish. By Saturday night we will know whether this was a weekend of nearly or the start of a week of finally. Which would you back to close it out first: Bafana in Nairobi, the Proteas at the Wanderers, or the Boks in Dublin?


